As you might imagine the vast majority of masons are not going to be familiar with historic masonry techniques and restoration much less have an appreciation for restoration work. Look for one that is experienced in historic restoration type work. The first thing that will come to mind is that this sounds like specialized expertise which equates to premium pricing. Not always the case if you shop around. But check references and inquire about restoration experience.

Try not to be dollar foolish. The wrong mason can leave you with a very permanent sad feeling and can actually diminish the historic character, curb appeal and value of your home. Drive around any old neighborhood and you’ll see sloppy, cost-prohibitive to reverse, Portland cement tuck pointing that will only get worse over time. Don’t be that home owner.

There are restoration experienced masons all over the country. For those local to Beloit and the broader stateline area one contractor you may want to contact is Bob Davis of Triple A Masonry here in Beloit. 608-290-1655.
We cannot make recommendations. There may be others in the area likewise experienced. Please check references and decide for yourself. I can tell you Bob is a wealth of information and willing to share if you’ve a question. I understand he’s currently working on an historic 1860′s home restoration locally.

Hope this helps. I applaud your interest in maintaining an important defining characteristic of your fine old home.